Perpetual motion machine designed by Leonardo da Vinci

Perpetual Motion

One of the most widely controversial topics in science is the concept of perpetual motion. Defined as “motion that continues forever without any external influences or additions”, perpetual motion has certainly captured the attention of scientists, engineers, and everyday people alike. Did you know that 70,000 plus people search online for information on the topic each year?

The allure is simple – getting some kind of work from a machine without relying on the environment or any fuel for power. The inventor of such a machine would be instantly famous, and probably more important, rich. However, as with all good things, the old saying of “there is no such thing as a free lunch” holds true for perpetual motion.

Even with the overwhelming evidence and scientific proof against the possibility of creating a perpetual motion machine, it hasn’t stopped people from searching for one. The long history of looking begins as early as the 8th century in Bavaria with the “magic wheel,” and continues through the ages until the present day.

Fludd Watermill of Perpetual Motion

Fludd Closed-Cycle Water Mill that violates First Law of Thermodynamics

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Notable names in science such as Nikola Tesla and Leonardo da Vinci have been involved with the search, either in creating designs and prototypes, or in debunking the theories of others. The course of time hasn’t changed the search either, just the technology. The first machines were based on mechanical wheels, hanging weights, and flowing water. Today’s machines incorporate newer concepts such as magnets and current fields.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

There are three main classifications of perpetual motion machines, those of the first, second, or third kind.

Machines of the First Kind:
Machines of the first kind produce work without any energy being input to the machine. This is a clear violation of the first law of thermodynamics, which says energy can neither be created, nor destroyed – only converted.

Machines of the Second Kind:
The second kind converts thermal energy into work, without any other inputs, at complete efficiency. While this doesn’t violate the first law (no energy is being created, just converted), these machines fall victim to the second law of thermodynamics. Slightly more difficult to understand, a simple breakdown says heat cannot only be taken from something to get work, without having a cooler reservoir to dump some part of that heat (thereby having some loss or inefficiency). Or, stated differently, a system always increases in entropy, or disorder.

Taisnierus Lodestone magnet Motor  for Perpetual Motion

Taisnieres Lodestone (magnet) Motor that violates the Second Law of Thermodynamics

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Machines of the Third Kind:
Machines of the third kind completely eliminate friction, and therefore continue a motion forever due to inertia. While many have tried, friction cannot be completely and utterly eliminated in any system.

Of the three kinds, machines that approach the third kind are the most useful, namely as a motion storage device. They will never produce energy, or do more work than was put into them, but extremely low friction loss can help to make these devices a reality. For example, in an area with sporadic power service, a heavy weight could be spun up to a high speed when power was available. Then, in times of no power service, the weight could be used to drive a generator. Some of the input energy would be lost to friction as the device spun, but the potential exists for a workable “battery” that could very well outperform traditional technologies in certain situations.

Despite the overwhelming scientific evidence to support the impossibility of perpetual motion, there are still those that refuse to believe, going as far as to say there is a large conspiracy between the technical community and fossil fuel manufacturers to keep potential free energy sources a secret. Contests and large monetary awards continue to be offered to the person who can create a functioning perpetual motion machine, much to the chagrin of the scientific community. The reasoning behind this mass fascination may truly be more philosophical than scientific, but that is probably better left up to the reader to decide.

For more information on perpetual motion, Kevin Kilty has a good article on the subject that is in depth without being overtly technical.

Share this Story
  • Perpetual motion machine designed by Leonardo da Vinci
    Featured Articles

    Perpetual Motion

    One of the most widely controversial topics in science is the concept of perpetual motion. Defined as “motion that continues forever ...
Load More Related Articles
Load More By Carlicia Layosa
Load More In Featured Articles

2 Comments


  1. JoeyP

    September 3, 2019 at 7:15 pm

    There is no such thing as “Perpetual Motion”, but I believe there is such thing as GRAVITY ASSIST, and if properly manipulated, should work. Are they useful? Probably not since there is going to be a net loss SOMEWHERE in this system (such as a differential of weight OR a differential of LEVERAGE). I think that such a machine, if it CAN be built would be VERY big, very heavy and not too much useful other than food for thought. but THY ARE interesting – somewhat skeptical

    Reply

  2. Denny

    October 24, 2019 at 8:52 pm

    One of the reasons that people(include me) focus on/pay attention to “Perpetual Motion”,just because they have a common idea: that “Perpetual Motion” is not ”creating something out of nothing“,it’s also a trick of “transformation of power/engery”, Any interchange will be governed by the conservation of energy, while the difficults we meet is the loss in the process in the energy conversion. well there are some thing such as :the existence of gravity, endless & powerful water flowing from a high mountain,warm sunshine…….., so, let’s be a little realistic, accuate design and calculation for enegy saving is our way better than dwelling on the illusion of “real Perpetual Motion”.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

Check Also

MISUMI Extrusion Protective Guard

Times are changing in many industries due to ...

Follow @misumiusa on Instagram

  • Even with 80 sextillion configurations, we know how important one part can be. Thank you to everyone doing their part in the fight against COVID-19. Link in bio #worldhealthday #80sextillion
  • MISUMI is on the move! We are excited to announce the relocation of our North American HQ to Glenstar’s Schaumburg Corporate Center. MISUMI is set to undergo a renovation of nearly 48,000 square feet spread over 2 floors of occupancy space. The relocation will allow a more expressive treatment of the MISUMI brand throughout the space. Read more, link in bio. #80Sextillion #ConfiguredToSaveTime
  • Wellness Fair at the office today. Thanks @chiroone @orangetheory  @weareonedigital #ConfiguredToBeHealthy #80sextillion
  • We crushed it at ATX West! Thanks to everyone who stopped by the MISUMI booth and crushed a can in the Bev-Bot 🔥. Let’s continue the conversation, find out how you can configure to save time. Link in bio. #atxwest #80sextillion #configuredtosavetime
  • MISUMI is excited to be at #slas2020 in San Diego. Are you attending? Stop by for a quick Rapid Design demo, and learn how you can save 30% design time! @slas_org #80sextillion
  • Head instructor John explains the different methods of proper installation for accuracy in linear guides during Master Class in Chicago. #80Sextillion #configuredtohavefun
  • Excited to be at #Engineer3D! in MKE. We started the day by kicking off the keynote presentation (swipe for the boomerang). We’re enjoying talking to and getting to know all the Engineers! Are you in attendance? Stop by the MISUMI booth to learn more about Rapid Design and get some swag #EnginerdOnBoard #gsc3d #80Sextillion #solidworks
  • We got spirit! Excited for football this Sunday 🏈 #configuredtohavefun #80Sextillion