linear guide

Sliding Guides, Part 2: Linear Bushings vs. Linear Guides

In the introduction to our sliding guides series, we looked at different types of guides and their various applications. This article will focus on the specific differences between linear bushings and linear guides. There are many options for each of these products, and each manufacturer tends to use some creative marketing descriptions as an enticement to purchase their product (and thus adding to the confusion). Most of this potential confusion belongs to the linear guide camp, so we’ll first look at linear bushings.

linear bushing
Linear Bushing Image from iMall

Linear Bushings

If you need a quick and easy way to facilitate a linear motion profile, the linear bushing is a great choice, especially if you don’t have high tolerance or accuracy requirements. Usually, two shafts are used to support a traveling carriage with linear bushings that slide along the shafts. The shafts must be sized to support the load within an acceptable deflection tolerance – too much weight and the shafts will bend, causing a positioning error. The bushing to shaft interface is also relatively loose, which can cause issues with accuracy and repeatability. However, these errors are typically small, on the order of a few thousandths of an inch. The setup and maintenance are also very inexpensive compared to other options.

Advantages:

  • Low-cost
  • Easy to install
  • Easy to maintain and service
  • Low friction

Disadvantages:

  • Potential for positioning errors
  • High speeds can cause problems

linear guideLinear Guide Image from MISUMI

Linear Guides

Demanding applications usually have solutions with demanding costs. Linear guides offer a great load capacity and higher rigidity for two main reasons:

  1. The ball bearings are usually sitting in an R- or V-shaped groove instead of using a plain contact, from which some manufacturers are claiming thirteen times as much load capacity.
  2. The guides are sitting directly on a base, so there is no deflection. Even a small (1” by 1.5”) linear guide can support a dynamic load of around 2,000 pounds.

Linear guides are also extremely accurate- errors are usually measured in the micrometers (μm) range. The addition of a preload into the guide can also increase accuracy and repeatability. Instead of having a small clearance between the track and the ball bearings, an interference fit is used.

Proper lubrication is a must to maintain a low friction, but the added rigidity can really make a difference. These factors combine together to give a very smooth operation for the guide.

misumi linear guideLinear Guide Image from Misumi

Advantages:

  • Amazing accuracy and repeatability
  • Higher load capacity and rigidity

Disadvantages:

  • Higher cost
  • Higher maintenance concerns

If you need to have high accuracy or high load capacity, there is nothing better than a linear guide. However, if you are just looking for a way to slide a mechanism back and forth, the linear bushing offers a great, low-cost alternative.

Still have questions, or have specific topics you would like us to cover in Part 3? Feel free to comment below, or email one of our experts at engineering@misumiusa.com.

2.5 (50%) 2 votes

Share this Story
Load More Related Articles
Load More By Brooke Bartos
Load More In Tips & Tricks

Check Also

Mastering Ball Screws Pt. 2: Ball Screw Preloads

Preloading is used to increase the feed accuracy and ...

Subscribe to our Channel

Follow Me @usa_misumi

Like us on Facebook

Find us on Google Plus

FOLLOW @ INSTAGRAM

  • The soccer champions of the Minnesota Futsal Festival sponsored by yours truly! #youthsoccer #winwin #goalie #sponsorship #sports
  • Our very own Segment Manager, James Lee, presented at a STEAM event at Heritage Elementary in Tustin, CA showing how MISUMI components are applied to daily life. #heritagesteam #heritage.jlee #steam #STEM #education
  • 1st MISUMI Chili Cookoff! Congrats to our Supplier Services Supervisor, Adriene, on winning Best Chili! 🌶 #chili #chilicookoff #officelife #chefs #yummy #lunchbreak #winning
  • We had a great time being an Ambassador in SME's Student Innovation Rocket Challenge at #FabTech17! #rocketscience #fabfech17 #sme #futureengineers
  • UPDATE: Life belt testing is in progress with over 1000hrs of running time under our belt. #puns #powertransmission #testing #gt #pulleys #engineering #enginerd #youvegotthepower
  • Bigfoot. Shout out to @makeitinc on their large scale 3D printer using #misumi aluminum extrusion, EFS series. They've printed parts for a Mazda Miata. What a beauty. #3dprinting #framework #design #bigfoot
  • Who wants to work on a Saturday? We do! Call or chat with us! #saturdays #happycaturday #workhard
  • Congrats to the MISUMI USA Recreational Softball team on their very first win yesterday in the Schaumburg Corporate Softball League!! #coedsoftball #proud #winners #wearenumberone #sports #softball #team